The following are some reasons Westerners think of Confucianism as a religion, though most Taiwanese do not consider it a religion.
The words "temple," "worship" and "pray" are often used by Taiwanese when referring to Confucianism. In English each of these words is closely linked to religion.
temple: this is usually a building for religious worship and the Chinese word for a building associated with Confucious. In contrast, when in America we wish to show our respect to a great individual without implying that he was a divinity or a god, we would build a memorial, such as the famous Lincoln or Washington memorials, in the person's honor.
worship: this is a deep respect and love usually shown or expressed for a god or divinity.
pray: before a big exam, students often pray for good scores at a Confucian Temple. But normally only a divine power can influence the future so again Westerners will conclude that Taiwanese believe Confucious was more than just a great man.
It is certainly true that Confucious is not regarded by anyone as a creator god, such as exists in the Western monotheistic (one God) religions. But the Taiwanese attitude towards Confucious suggests to Westerners that at the very least he is considered divine.
I should also mention Wing-Tsit Chan's (A Source Book in Chinese Philosophy) commentary on K'and Yu-Wei, the Chinese philosopher and reformer (1858-1927): "K'ang was the first to regard Confucious as the founder of a religion, and he vigorously advocated Confucionism as the state religion." This of course suggests my opinion is in the minority.
Experience
Teaching Taiwanese since 2005 | FREE 30-minute trial classes available!
Bernard English
Online English Tutor/Teacher
- Native Speaker of American English Conversation practice. Chatting or in-depth discussion of news articles. TOEFL-IELTS practice / CV, SOP, journal paper, essay revision 英語家教 彈性排課, 免通勤, 托福, 職場英文, 履歷/論文修改…等。 請看我的學生推薦信。
Search This Blog
email: bernard.english@gmail.com
Thursday, July 12, 2007
Why Westerners Think Confuciounism is a Religion
Labels:
4. Vocabulary,
by Bernard
Native Speaker of American English
Conversation practice. Chatting or in-depth discussion of news articles.
TOEFL-IELTS practice / CV, SOP, journal paper, essay revision
英語家教
彈性排課, 免通勤, 托福, 職場英文, 履歷/論文修改…等。
請看我的學生推薦信。
Labels
- 1. Oral Speech (20)
- 2. Writing Tips (11)
- 3. Oral Presentation (5)
- 4. Vocabulary (33)
- 5. Grammar (7)
- 6. Applying for a Job (18)
- 7. Applying to Schools (20)
- 8. Test Preparation (6)
- 9. Audio/Video (230)
- 9. Audio/Video Military (5)
- Africa (2)
- Animals (8)
- Art (13)
- audio (1)
- BBC Learning English (2)
- Biography (21)
- biology (32)
- Book Review (22)
- Business (195)
- by Bernard (23)
- Case Studies (3)
- Celebrities (2)
- China (18)
- Clothes (9)
- Colbert (1)
- Computers/Internet (124)
- Covid (85)
- Crime (144)
- crime. military (2)
- Culture/Ethnicity (92)
- Eco (1)
- Economics (524)
- Education (159)
- Energy (1)
- Environment (93)
- Ethics (110)
- ethni (1)
- ethnic (2)
- Europe (1)
- Family (42)
- Finance (8)
- Food (77)
- Gender (33)
- Government (9)
- Health (278)
- History (18)
- Hobbies (9)
- housing (4)
- Humor (54)
- Immigration (32)
- Inspiration (5)
- International Comparisons (12)
- Investing (74)
- Japanese Classes (1)
- Japanese Vocabulary (4)
- Language (46)
- Law (133)
- Libertarian (3)
- Lockdowns crime (1)
- Media (59)
- Military (368)
- Miscellaneous (80)
- Movie Review (3)
- Music (13)
- Obituary (1)
- pandemic (4)
- poli (1)
- Politics (367)
- Psychology (267)
- Quizzes (1)
- Quotes (22)
- Religion (46)
- Romance/Marriage (57)
- Science (187)
- Shopping (10)
- Sports (77)
- Supernatural and UFO (6)
- Taiwan (29)
- Television and Movies (14)
- The Elderly (4)
- The Elderly/Retirement (19)
- The Youth (33)
- TOEFL (2)
- Transportation (51)
- Travel (20)
- U.S. (3)
- US History (49)
- USA (26)
- Vices (28)
- War (4)
- Weather (5)
- Work (119)
- Writing Contest (7)